After watching one IU Football practice, I’m not as hopeful as I would like – and I’m an optimist

If I had to pick a starting QB for IU, it would be Michael Penix because in thew unknown, there is hope.

There is this feeling in my gut that criticizing Indiana University’s football program is unfair.  Indiana fans have nothing but hope to keep them coming back to Memorial Stadium – well, hope and beer.

It hurts to write a post that doesn’t help IU fans hope.

Hope in IU Football has almost always poorly invested as the horrifying reality becomes apparent soon enough.  It’s just enough to get fans through September’s beautiful Saturdays before the fall overcast skies, chills, and Big 10 opponents ruin the fun.

I went to an IU Football practice yesterday in search of some justification for hope.  I want to believe in IU Football, so I watched practice looking for positives.

Click here for a $1 comprehensive dental exam done by the best dentist in Indiana – Dr. Mike O’Neil at Today’s Dentistry

Before I go any further, it’s important to understand I have gone to a total of that one single practice, and that practice was held 18 days before the season opener at Lucas Oil Stadium against Ball State.  To go to one practice and believe you have all the answers about a football team is arrogant and stupid.

When I left, my only reasons for hope are that I saw the Hoosiers on the wrong day, my sample size was too small, and I don’t know enough about football to accurate appraise a team in two hours of paying attention to them.

I’m usually pretty good at talking myself into believing in a team.  I am to sports teams as the guy at the end of the bar at closing time is to women finishing their last drinks.  They are all good looking enough to squint and see the good.


I squinted like hell yesterday.  I turned my head sideways.  I spun in a circle to make myself dizzy.  But I couldn’t find a reason to believe IU can find a way to go to win three games against Big 10 teams.

There is a saying in football that if you have two starting quarterbacks, you don’t have any starting quarterbacks.  I can’t find a saying about having three starting QBs, but that is what coach Tom Allen insists he has.

Peyton Ramsey, Michael Penix, and Jack Tuttle are competing for the top spot, just as Peyton Ramsey, Michael Penix, and Brandon Dawkins were neck and neck and neck last year.

Ramsey won the job for 2018 and started all 12 games.  Clearly, his work wasn’t enough to earn him the job for 2019 or Allen would already have named him the starter.  Penix has fully recovered from a torn ACL and is quite mobile.  Tuttle transferred to IU from Utah.

Ramsey is the known quantity – low risk, low reward.  Penix is the athletic wild card – high risk, high reward.  Tuttle appears to be at least a year away despite a good arm.

The defense looked good, but it should given the uncertainty at quarterback and a great familiarity of IU’s offensive schemes.

Allen encouraged and barked into a megaphone in equal measure.  He was not nearly as frenetic during practice as during games, but still seemed much more comfortable coaching kids than delegating authority to his coordinators and position coaches.

I would love to write that I believe Indiana is going bowling in December, but I can’t.  I’ll still be down there for the six home game Saturdays this fall, but it looks like the beer and laughs will be the big reason – again – for my attendance.  Hope I’m wrong about that.

3 thoughts on “After watching one IU Football practice, I’m not as hopeful as I would like – and I’m an optimist

  1. private

    This has to be the most poorly written article I have ever read. I hope they kick you out of Memorial Stadium and never let you back on the sidelines or access to the team.

  2. Hoosier hype man

    Do they actually pay you for writing such garbage? If I see you in Memorial Stadium I’ll beat your ass.

  3. Paul D Talbott

    It would have been nice if you could have articulated even one reason for your negative takeaway from the IU practice (i.e. receivers can’t catch, quarterbacks can’t throw, RBs fumbling every play). Granted, there is never any reason to be overly optimistic where IU FB is concerned, but at be prepared to back up your gut with some actual facts.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *