Post-Season Looks Like Regular Season – Andrew Luck Covers Up Flaws

by Bert Beiswanger


Andrew Luck making a play that defines greatness.

Let’s not sugar coat this, folks: The Colts beat an average football team Sunday. They don’t need to apologize for that – a win in the NFL Playoffs is a great win.

But the fact is the Bengals came into the game without # 2 wide receiver Marvin Jones (out all year), without #1 wide receiver and difference-maker A.J. Green, and without tight ends Tyler Eifert (out all but one quarter this year) and Jermaine Gresham.

Another fact is the Colts have the goal of doing more than winning this game. Had the Colts not won this game, there would be some serious and appropriate outrage today among the fan base. Losing this game at home to this Bengals team was not an option.

Andy Dalton is a popular quarterback to criticize. Marvin Lewis is a popular coach to criticize. But I’d choose another year to do so. The Bengals got the most out of what they had this season, particularly at the end. When a team has zero weapons down field and is nothing more than a one-dimensional running team like Cincinnati was Sunday, that doesn’t work too well in the NFL Playoffs.

Let’s also not sugar coat this: Andrew Luck is spectacular. The 36-yard TD pass to Donte Moncrief was everything that is Andrew Luck wrapped into one – strength, poise, athleticism, play-making ability. I immediately said to my son, “Look at that..THAT is why Luck is so special.”

Luck has also received some criticism this year for not taking care of the football. But without a running game half the year and a mediocre offensive line in a constant state of flux, I’d also choose another year to criticize Andrew Luck. I heard some critics late in the year, I did, as much as it made me shake my head with confusion. But I’d say he did a pretty good job of shutting them up Sunday.

No quarterback carries the burden of a team and covers up flaws more than Andrew Luck. Luck is the epitome of a team MVP.

Back to the game Sunday:

  • Senseless Penalties – nine total and two false starts by Dwayne Allen in one drive to kill the drive. A Donte Moncrief penalty negated a Coby Fleener touchdown. The 2013 Colts were the best in the league when it came to fewest penalties per game. What has changed, I’m not entirely sure (the 2014 Colts are mid-pack). But nine penalties won’t get it done in the Playoffs
  • Drops, drops and more drops. Hey, the Colts led the league in drops. What else is new? It cost them 10-14 points Sunday. That simply can’t happen next week.
  • Turnovers – “Boom” Herron is catching flack for not holding onto the ball. The fact the Colts only had one turnover Sunday is actually a positive. Indianapolis ranks near the bottom of the league in giveaways per game, along with teams like New Orleans, Washington and Tampa Bay. When it comes to teams with the fewest turnovers per game, six of the top seven are playoff teams – New England, Green Bay, Seattle, Arizona, Baltimore and Denver. The seventh was Kansas City. Stats don’t lie: the best teams in the league take care of the football.

You can overcome all of that against against that Bengals team. You can’t against Denver. Shoot, one turnover may be one too many against Denver.

The bottom line is the lack of discipline and fundamentals have been an issue this year. The Colts are good enough to beat a Bengals team that limped into Sunday’s playoff game, but haven’t been good enough to beat the elite in the league this year. So, everything you saw yesterday; that’s not good enough to beat Denver or New England.

Make no mistake, I will take a win in the NFL any day and not apologize for it, particularly an NFL Playoffs win. The Colts played well enough Sunday and have every reason to feel good about once again being in the AFC semi-finals.

But people within and outside the organization talk about this team taking the next step this year. Can it win at Denver? Absolutely, the Colts can win at Denver. They certainly have a punchers chance. When you have a heavyweight like Andrew Luck, you are in every single game. I’d give the Colts a 33.3% chance to win Sunday. That may sound rough, but that’s simply the tale of the tape.

To beat the best in the playoffs takes fundamental, mistake-free football; something the Colts haven’t done against the best all season long (the 66.6% portion of the odds at Denver).

Denver is sputtering a little right now (by Denver standards). The Broncos are a little banged up. So the game is there for the Colts to win, IF the Colts play mistake-free football across the board. If the Colts go to Denver and win, it will be because they played better than they did Sunday and probably better all around than they have all year.

Follow on Twitter @BertBeis


5 thoughts on “Post-Season Looks Like Regular Season – Andrew Luck Covers Up Flaws

  1. Booger McGee

    This same Bengals team beat the Broncos 3 weeks ago…Green was injured that game (1st quarter) and didnt participate for most of the game. So making excuses for why the Bungals lost doesnt work for me. Colts beat a team they know how to beat, but if this Bengals team could beat Denver so can the Colts. This Denver team is not as good as they were touted to be at the beginning of the season.

    1. kentsterling

      I’m with you. The more I watch Broncos tape, the less impressed I am. Getting off to a good start is key for the Colts.

  2. Bert B

    No excuses booger, that game was in cincy and they at least had Gresham. Point is luck is so good no qb in the league carries more of a burden for his team. And luck covers up many flaws. The colts absolutely should have won this game easily and they did. The bengals were one dimensional.

  3. Bert B.

    Listening to the best football voice/mind on local radio – coach Rick Venturi – always a must listen. He’s communicating what I tried to communicate (heard him earlier in the week, too). The Bengals were a wounded tiger, a one-dimensional team without any down field weapons – pretty straight-forward to defend. The Colts haven’t beaten a multi dimensional team like Denver all year. The Bengals aren’t much of a barometer. To beat DEN , the Colts must eliminate bad drops, turnovers and senseless undisciplined penalties. Denver is banged up some and trending in the wrong direction. They are definitely beatable because of that. But for the Colts to win at Denver, they need to play better than the Cincy game across the board – probably better than any game all year. Luck can’t do it all. But, yes, with Manning not the same and other issues, they are beatable


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *